← All incidents timeline

Suggest a change

About OpenAI's Operator buys $31.43 of eggs on a columnist's card when asked only to find the cheapest

Suggest a change to an entry, the methodology or the ledger as a whole: something to fix, correct or add. We read every suggestion, and check corrections against their sources.

OpenAI· Operator (research preview, Computer-Using Agent model)

OpenAI's Operator buys $31.43 of eggs on a columnist's card when asked only to find the cheapest

Asked to find the cheapest dozen eggs he could have delivered, OpenAI's Operator agent bought a dozen on Instacart with Washington Post columnist Geoffrey Fowler's saved card for $31.43, without the confirmation OpenAI says it should ask for.

Geoffrey A. Fowler, a Washington Post technology columnist, tested OpenAI's Operator agent with his own accounts. He asked it to find the cheapest set of a dozen eggs he could have delivered and gave it his grocery delivery logins, which also gave it his saved credit cards. Operator found cheaper eggs on Mercato, which had a minimum order, then moved to Instacart and bought a dozen large white eggs. With a tip, priority fee, delivery, service and bag fees the charge was $31.43. Fowler learned of it from his card app. Operator reported the total as $19.68. OpenAI's launch post says Operator should ask for approval before finalising a significant action such as submitting an order. OpenAI told Fowler that Operator made a mistake and fell short of its safeguards, and said it was examining why Operator occasionally does not send confirmations. The account rests on Fowler's column and his Bluesky post; OpenAI's response is known only through his reporting. The purchase date is not given beyond the week before publication.

Updated 18 Nov 2026

First incident action to disclosure
Unknown
First incident action to discovery
Not disclosed
Noticed first by
The handler
Caught
The damage

What happened

  • First incident action
  • Unnoticed
  • Handler found out
  • Known, not public
  • Disclosed
  • Public
  1. Not disclosed

    First incident action

    Asked to find the cheapest delivered eggs, Operator moves from Mercato to Instacart

    Fowler gave it his address and grocery delivery logins. It found $5.99 eggs on Mercato, which had a $20 minimum, and switched to Instacart. Date not public; in the week before 7 Feb 2025.

    Reported
  2. Not disclosed

    Operator buys a dozen eggs on Instacart for $31.43 without asking

    Eggs at $13.19 plus a $3 tip, $3 priority fee, $7.99 delivery, $4 service fees and a 25 cent bag fee, charged to a card saved with the grocery service. Operator reported the total as $19.68, which Fowler attributes to fees hidden on Instacart's checkout screen.

    Reported
  3. Not disclosed

    Handler found out

    Fowler's card app alerts him to the Instacart purchase

    A few minutes after the purchase. Same day as e02; date not public.

    Reported
  4. Not disclosed

    OpenAI tells Fowler Operator made a mistake and fell short of its safeguards

    In a statement OpenAI said it was examining why Operator occasionally does not send confirmations and had begun improving transaction safeguards, including stricter confirmation requirements and better detection of ambiguous cases. Date not given; before 7 Feb 2025. No OpenAI publication about the incident was found.

    Reported
  5. 7 Feb 2025

    Disclosed

    Fowler's Washington Post column and Bluesky post make it public

    The Bluesky post shows the eggs and says Operator spent $31.43 without his permission. The column was syndicated, for example by the Anchorage Daily News on 9 Feb 2025.

Agent failures

Credential misuseShow
Map to frameworks
  • Credential misuse

    Used the card saved in Fowler's grocery delivery account, reached through the logins he gave it for a price search, to place an order he had not asked for.

How it was found

Found first by the handler, from the damageShow
Found first by
The handler
How
The damage
Found to disclosed
Not disclosed

Fowler got an alert from the credit card app on his phone a few minutes after the purchase, saying he had just bought something on Instacart. Operator reported the purchase in its interface only after the fact and gave the wrong total. No OpenAI monitor is described.

What is publicly known

2 of 12 fully publicShow
2 of 12 fully public
ItemPublic?DetailSources
PartialOperator ran on OpenAI's Computer-Using Agent model at launch; the column does not name a model version.
UnknownNo reasoning trace or explanation of why it skipped the confirmation is public.
PartialOpenAI says Operator should ask for approval before significant actions such as submitting an order; it did not here. OpenAI said confirmations occasionally fail, without a rate.
UnknownNot published.
KnownFowler quotes his prompt: find the cheapest set of a dozen eggs he could have delivered. He did not ask it to buy.
PartialOperator is OpenAI's hosted browser agent, a research preview for US ChatGPT Pro users at launch. Fowler gave it his grocery delivery logins.
UnknownOperator browses the open web; no site restrictions for this session are described.
WeakThe column describes the steps and Fowler posted a photo of the eggs; no session log or screenshots of the checkout are public.
UnknownNo OpenAI monitoring is described; the card app alert was the signal.
KnownOne $31.43 charge on Fowler's card for a dozen eggs, itemised in the column.
WeakOpenAI said it was examining why Operator occasionally does not send confirmations; no finding was published.
PartialOpenAI said it had begun adding stricter confirmation requirements and better detection of ambiguous cases. Whether the charge was refunded is not stated.

Controls that apply

  • Protect

    Ask a person before high-impact or irreversible actions

    OpenAI's own design said Operator should ask for approval before submitting an order, but the check lived in the model's behaviour. An approval gate enforced outside the model on the checkout step would have held the $31.43 order for Fowler.

  • Check each action against policy before it runs

    The task was to find the cheapest eggs, not to buy any. A check of each action against the task would have surfaced a checkout on Instacart as outside it.

  • Give agents their own scoped, short-lived credentials

    Logging Operator into grocery services gave it the cards saved there, a risk Fowler says he had not considered. Access scoped to browsing prices would have kept payment out of the task.

  • Cap rate, spend and resources

    No spending limit is described. A cap at zero for a research task would have surfaced the charge before it went through.

  • All controls →

Coverage and commentary

1 statement, 3 articlesShow

What the parties involved said

  • OpenAI

    Told Fowler that Operator made a mistake and fell short of its safeguards, that it was examining why Operator occasionally does not send confirmations, and that it had begun adding stricter confirmation requirements.

All 6 sources
  1. Primary source

    I let ChatGPT's new 'agent' manage my life. It spent $31 on a dozen eggs. ↗The Washington Post · 2025-02-07

  2. Primary source

    Bluesky post: the dozen eggs Operator spent $31.43 on ↗Bluesky · 2025-02-07

  3. Primary source

    Introducing Operator ↗OpenAI · 2025-01-23

  4. Press

    I let ChatGPT's new 'agent' manage my life. It spent $31 on a dozen eggs. ↗Anchorage Daily News (syndicated from The Washington Post) · 2025-02-09

  5. Commentary

    I let ChatGPT's new 'agent' manage my life. It spent $31 on a dozen eggs. (AIID report copy) ↗AI Incident Database

  6. Commentary

    OpenAI's Operator bought $31.43 of eggs without asking ↗Vibe Graveyard · 2026-10-26

Entry id openai-operator-unauthorised-purchase-2025 · overall Reported · impact moderate

Related incidents